Performance: Significantly underperformed or failed to meet expectations.
Impact: Minimal or negative impact on the team (e.g. inconsistent, injury-prone).
Value: Poor return on investment; overpriced relative to contribution.
Performance: Occasional flashes of quality but generally below par.
Impact: Limited contribution or inconsistent influence on team results.
Value: Mediocre value for money; transfer fee/wages seem excessive compared to output.
Performance: Meets basic expectations without excelling.
Impact: Reliable squad player or contributor in specific situations.
Value: Fair value for the cost; neither a bargain nor a waste.
Performance: Exceeded expectations, consistently strong performances.
Impact: Significant positive influence on team dynamics and results.
Value: Represents good value for money, justifying the transfer fee/wages.
Performance: Outstanding, transformative player, regularly delivering at the highest level.
Impact: Key contributor to the team's success and improvement.
Value: A bargain or justified high cost; a transfer masterstroke.